MikroTik CSS318-16G-S+IN Review A New Low Cost 10-in Switch

4

MikroTik CSS318-16G-S+IN Management

As the “CSS” name suggests, this is a MikroTik SwOS switch. Many STH readers are familiar with MikroTik RouterOS. SwOS is the simplified OS for switches.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Link
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Link

We get some nice-to-have features like SFP information in the UI. We are just going to show the screens here since they are fairly self-evident and we want to give folks a flavor of SwOS.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS SFP Info
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS SFP Info

Here is a shot at the Port Isolation.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Port Isolation
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Port Isolation

Here is link aggregation.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Link Aggregation
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Link Aggregation

This is the forwarding screen.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Forwarding
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS Forwarding

This is RSTP.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS RSTP
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS RSTP

Here is the VLAN setup screen:

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS VLAN
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS VLAN

This is the ACL screen:

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS ACL
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS ACL

This is the System tab.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS System
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN SwOS System

Something small, but also nice that MikroTik has that many other switches in this price range do not is the ability to update either via file repository. That may seem like a small feature, but it makes things very easy to update.

MikroTik SwOS Update
MikroTik SwOS Update

Next, let us discuss performance.

MikroTik CSS318-16G-S+IN Performance

Here is a quick look at MikroTik’s numbers for the switch:

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Performance From MikroTik
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Performance From MikroTik

Our numbers largely mirrored what we would expect.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Performance
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Performance

Overall, 1GbE and 10GbE switch silicon is mature at this point, so this is what we would expect.

MikroTik CSS318-16G-S+IN Power Consumption

In terms of power consumption, we saw 3.3W at idle.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Idle
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Idle

Adding a 1GbE port linked up made power consumption jump to 3.6W.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Power 1GbE
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Power 1GbE

Adding a SFP+ to 10Gbase-T adapter saw power hit 5W.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Power 10Gbase T Adapter
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Power 10Gbase T Adapter

MikroTik says that the switch uses 10W maximum without attachments and 13W at most, making this a relatively low-power switch. Also, since it is fanless, it is quiet.

MikroTik CSS318-16G-S+IN 10″ Rack Install

Installing this into racks, MikroTik supplies both full-width and half-width rack ears.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Rack Ears
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Rack Ears

Here is a quick look at the switch in a DeskPi 10″ rack switch:

MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 1
MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 1

Something small that we noticed is that we could only install it on one side. One side of the rack allowed the switch to fit easily. The other side left this switch a few mm too wide.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 2
MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 2

At first, we thought that was a fluke, but it happened on other 10″ racks as well. For example, in the video, we showed how we had to untighten the posts on another rack to fit the switch.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 3
MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 3

This led to a strange observation. Unlike the 19″ rack sector where rack widths are very consistent, we ran into challenges with four of the six 10″ racks we tried, mostly due to the quality control of screwing in posts in adjustable racks.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 4
MikroTik CSS318 16G 4S+IN In 10 In Racks 4

This is the type of thing that can be very frustrating for folks. In the future, it would be nice if MikroTik made its chassis slightly narrower and its rack ears slightly longer to account for this 10″ rack variance (this had no problems in 19″ racks.) It feels like MikroTik built the CSS318-16G-4S+IN to a 222.25mm or 8.75″ spec, but in the 10″ rack world, things can often be slightly out of spec. Given its width, even putting it on a 10″ shelf instead of rack ears is challening because most 10″ rack shelves assume a bigger variance of rack widths, so they do not have enough room to accomodate the switch. MikroTik needs to shave a few mm from the width of this to make it fit better. It is really strange they did not do so.

Final Words

At a $139 list price, we are already seeing street pricing in the $107-115 range. While this is a far cry from some of the cheapest switches in the segment, if you just need this port configuration from a switch designed in Latvia and built in Malaysia, then this is a good option. Still, the talk around STH was more about how much more useful this would be if it was a 2.5GbE switch, and/or had PoE+ capabilities. 1GbE is quickly becoming the domain of management interfaces, small developer boards like Raspberry Pi’s or the NVIDIA Jetson Orin, and older Project TinyMiniMicro nodes. It would certainly cost more, but we wish MikroTik made this. MikroTik has the CRS318-16P-2S+OUT aka the netPower 16P, but that is meant for outdoor PoE+ installation, not 10″ rack installation.

MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Front 2
MikroTik CSS318 16G 2S+IN Front 2

The fact that we want more does not make this bad. Indeed, if you just need 1GbE and the narrower form factor, then the MikroTik CSS318-16G-2S+IN is a neat little form factor switch.

4 COMMENTS

  1. If they release this with 4 SFP+ and 2.5GbE it’s going to be a best seller I think. Should easily be possible with the new Marvell Prestera chips that Mikrotik uses.

  2. Why do companies keep releasing new products with 1GbE ports? Very frustrating when I see something that checks all but one box. Feels like I’m back in 2003 when looking for gigabit devices and running into 100Mbit products everywhere.

  3. I agree with David – if they were to release this with 4x SFP+ ports AND 2.5GbE on the rest of the switch, it would hands-down be one of if not THE most flexible and desirable home/small-business switches on the market. 10 inch rack compatibility or not.

    A bunch of gigabit jacks and just two SFP+ ports though? Meh, pass.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.